New Delhi, September 1, 2023 – In a significant move towards overhauling India’s intricate electoral system, a high-powered committee has been established to delve into the viability of adopting a ‘One Nation, One Election’ model. Chaired by former President Ram Nath Kovind, this committee has embarked on an ambitious mission to scrutinize the advantages and complexities surrounding the synchronization of national and state-level elections across the vast Indian landscape. The ‘One Nation, One Election‘ concept has long been a subject of debate, and this initiative marks a renewed endeavor to bring about fundamental changes in India’s electoral landscape.
The Committee’s Scope and Purpose ( One Nation, One Election)
The primary objective of this committee is to evaluate whether India can transition to a ‘One Nation, One Election’ system, wherein both the Lok Sabha (national) and state assembly elections are held simultaneously. The core rationale behind this proposition is to enhance efficiency and cost-effectiveness in the electoral process, streamlining the nation’s democratic machinery.
A Glimpse into India’s Electoral Evolution
India’s electoral journey since becoming a democratic republic in 1950 has witnessed significant transformations. In its nascent years, simultaneous elections were the norm, with four such elections conducted until 1967. However, this practice was disrupted when certain state assemblies were dissolved prematurely in 1968-69. Subsequently, the Lok Sabha was dissolved a year ahead of schedule in 1970, leading to mid-term elections in 1971.
The ‘One Nation, One Election’ concept is not a recent phenomenon; it has been a recurring topic of discussion over the years. In fact, it found a prominent place in the Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) 2014 Lok Sabha Election Manifesto, wherein the party pledged to work on a methodology for conducting simultaneous Assembly and Lok Sabha elections.
Also Read on G20 INDIA Summit
The BJP’s Steadfast Advocacy
The BJP, under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, has consistently advocated for synchronized elections. The party has emphasized that holding elections at different times places a substantial burden on the nation’s resources and disrupts the continuity of governance. The concept has not merely been a campaign promise but an enduring commitment of the ruling party.
Prime Minister Modi’s Vision for Simultaneous Elections
Prime Minister Modi’s interest in the idea of simultaneous elections can be traced back to 2016 when he first voiced his support for this innovative approach. Following the Lok Sabha elections in 2019, he convened an all-party meeting to discuss the issue. However, this meeting was marked by the conspicuous absence of several opposition parties, underscoring the deep-seated divisions on this matter.
Prime Minister Modi has consistently argued that the ‘One Nation, One Election’ concept could result in substantial savings, both in terms of financial resources and time. Proponents believe that such an approach would enable governments to focus on governance rather than being perpetually caught in election mode.
Skepticism in the Opposition Ranks
While the ruling party extols the virtues of simultaneous elections, the opposition remains skeptical. Critics contend that the BJP’s fixation on ‘one nation, one’ concepts, encompassing culture, religion, and party, erodes the rich diversity and pluralism inherent to India’s democracy.
D. Raja, the General Secretary of the Communist Party of India, voiced this skepticism, highlighting that the BJP’s focus on ‘one nation, one election’ is part of a broader trend. He argued that it reflects an overarching agenda to homogenize India’s diverse cultural, religious, and political landscape. Raja also expressed concerns about the increasing marginalization of Parliament, suggesting that the government’s actions are undermining its constitutional supremacy.
The Enigmatic Special Session of Parliament
The formation of the committee tasked with exploring ‘One Nation, One Election’ comes on the heels of an unexpected announcement by the Central government. A special session of Parliament is scheduled from September 18 to 22, but the session’s agenda remains shrouded in secrecy. Speculation is rife that a bill pertaining to ‘One Nation, One Election’ might be introduced during this session, although no official confirmation has been forthcoming.
Navigating the Complex Terrain of Electoral Reform
As India contemplates the transition to ‘One Nation, One Election,’ it must confront a multitude of pivotal questions and challenges.
- Constitutional Amendments: The implementation of this system would necessitate extensive constitutional amendments since the terms of state assemblies and the Lok Sabha are currently unsynchronized.
- Logistics and Infrastructure: The logistics of conducting simultaneous elections on a nationwide scale pose formidable challenges, including the need for an expanded fleet of electronic voting machines (EVMs) and additional personnel.
- Economic Considerations: While proponents argue that cost savings could be substantial, the initial investments in infrastructure upgrades and coordination efforts must be factored into the equation.
- Impact on Regional Parties: Smaller regional parties may find themselves at a disadvantage in a synchronized election scenario, as they could struggle to compete with national parties possessing greater resources and visibility.
- Role of the Election Commission: The Election Commission of India would assume a pivotal role in overseeing the logistics and coordination of this massive electoral undertaking.
- Development of a Comprehensive Legal Framework: The establishment of a comprehensive legal framework is imperative to address the myriad facets of simultaneous elections, including the premature dissolution of state assemblies.
The Path Forward
The establishment of the committee, chaired by former President Ram Nath Kovind, marks a momentous development in India’s political landscape. While proponents argue that ‘One Nation, One Election’ could usher in efficiency and substantial cost savings, critics raise apprehensions about the potential ramifications for India’s multifarious democracy.
The journey towards implementing simultaneous elections is fraught with challenges, including the necessity for constitutional amendments and the intricacies of logistics. The debate surrounding this issue will continue to shape India’s electoral landscape, and only time will tell whether the nation will ultimately embrace this ambitious reform. The forthcoming special session of Parliament is likely to provide further insights into the government’s intentions and the trajectory of India’s electoral system.
the exploration of ‘One Nation, One Election’ represents a significant milestone in India’s democratic journey. The nation stands at a crossroads, deliberating the merits and pitfalls of this groundbreaking electoral reform. As India contemplates these profound changes, it reaffirms its commitment to the principles of democracy and the pursuit of a more efficient and responsive governance system.
[…] Also Read ONE NATION ONE ELECTION […]